Nigeria’s legal order is characterised by the simultaneous operation of constitutional law, legislation, customary law, Islamic law and regional and international human-rights standards. Although formal guarantees prohibit discrimination on grounds including sex, women’s substantive enjoyment of rights remains uneven, especially in inheritance, matrimonial property, custody, harmful practices and access to justice. This article critically examines how Nigeria can reconcile customary and cultural norms with constitutional and international standards without treating customary law either as immune from review or as incapable of development. It adopts comparative legal analysis of constitutional provisions, legislation, reported judicial decisions, regional and international instruments and recent socio-legal scholarship. Particular attention is paid to the judicial trajectory from Mojekwu v Mojekwu through Ukeje v Ukeje and Anekwe v Nweke to the 2024 Court of Appeal decision in Fidelis Agbege v Shedrack Oriloye. The analysis finds that Nigerian courts have increasingly rejected discriminatory customary rules, but formal legal gains remain constrained by fragmented implementation, weak enforcement, limited legal awareness and the continuing social authority of discriminatory norms. The article argues for rights-compatible legal pluralism: customary law should remain capable of culturally legitimate evolution, while constitutional equality and human dignity operate as non-negotiable limits. Sustainable reform, therefore, requires doctrinal coherence, effective institutions, accessible remedies and locally grounded legal education.
Keywords: Women’s Rights; Legal Pluralism; Customary Law; Gender Equality; Constitutional Law; Human Rights; Inheritance; Nigeria.
Okoye, C. C. (2026). Women’s Rights In a Plural Legal Order: Reconciling Customary Law, Cultural Practices and International Human Rights Standards in Nigeria.. British Journal of Advanced Research, 1(4), Article 021. https://doi.org/10.68263/BJAR-7P6GPFNY
MLA
Okoye, Christian Chinemelum. "Women’s Rights In a Plural Legal Order: Reconciling Customary Law, Cultural Practices and International Human Rights Standards in Nigeria.." British Journal of Advanced Research, vol. 1, no. 4, 2026, article 021. DOI: https://doi.org/10.68263/BJAR-7P6GPFNY
Chicago
Okoye, Christian Chinemelum. "Women’s Rights In a Plural Legal Order: Reconciling Customary Law, Cultural Practices and International Human Rights Standards in Nigeria.." British Journal of Advanced Research 1, no. 4 (2026): 021. https://doi.org/10.68263/BJAR-7P6GPFNY
References
Abimbola FO, Ehiane SO and Tandlich R, ‘Women’s Rights in Nigeria’s Indigenous Systems: An Analysis of Non-Discrimination and Equality under International Human Rights Law’ (2023) 12 Social Sciences 405
Acharya A, ‘How Ideas Spread: Whose Norms Matter? Norm Localization and Institutional Change in Asian Regionalism’ (2004) 58 International Organization 239
Diala AC, ‘The Shadow of Legal Pluralism in Matrimonial Property Division Outside the Courts in Southern Nigeria’ (2018) 18 African Human Rights Law Journal 706
Diala AC, ‘Legal Pluralism and the Future of Personal Family Laws in Africa’ (2021) 35 International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family ebab023
Diala AC and Adeleke V, ‘A Legal Pluralist Analysis of State Protection of Women’s Child Custody Rights in Southern Nigeria’ (2026) 41 Southern African Public Law 1
Diala AC and Diala JC, ‘Normative Intersectionality in Married Women’s Property Rights in Southern Nigeria’ (2020) 24 Law, Democracy and Development 86
Durojaye E and Owoeye Y, ‘“Equally Unequal or Unequally Equal”: Adopting a Substantive Equality Approach to Gender Discrimination in Nigeria’ (2017) 17 International Journal of Discrimination and the Law 70
Efe CJ and Eberechi OE, ‘Property Rights of Nigerian Women at Divorce: A Case for a Redistribution Order’ (2020) 23 Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal 1
Ezeilo JN, ‘Rethinking Women and Customary Inheritance in Nigeria’ (2021) 47 Commonwealth Law Bulletin 706
Eyongndi DT-A, Opara FN, Oladele OO, Agbu DA and Ajayi M-AO, ‘Realising Female Inheritance Rights in South Eastern Nigeria: The Imperativeness of Going Beyond Legal Rhetoric’ (2024) 22 The Age of Human Rights Journal e7972
Ikuteyijo OO, Martin Hilber A, Fatusi AO, Akinyemi AI and Merten S, ‘Stakeholders’ Engagement with Law to Address Gender-Based Violence in Southwest Nigeria: A Qualitative Study Using Normalisation Process Theory to Explore Implementation Challenges’ (2024) 2 BMJ Public Health e001326
Nwaechefu H, Adekunle TK, Morojele R, Ojekunle AO, Nnawulezi U, Ajah MC and Igwe I, ‘Enforcing the Inheritance Rights of Women: A Comparative Paradigm of South East Nigeria and Somalia’ (2025) 12(2) Journal of Somali Studies 9
Okwuadinma OS and Gasiokwu PI, ‘The Right to Female Succession-Inheritance under Native Laws and Customs in Nigeria: An Affront to Justice’ (2024) 12 Global Journal of Politics and Law Research 98
Olusegun OO and Oyelade OS, ‘Access to Justice for Nigerian Women: A Veritable Tool to Achieving Sustainable Development’ (2022) 22 International Journal of Discrimination and the Law 4
Owolabi KMW, ‘Women’s Inheritance Rights under Islamic Law in Nigeria: Between Religious Norms, Customary Practices, and ADR Remedies’ (2025) 4 KWASU Law Journal 189
Oyinloye OBA and Agunbiade F, ‘Understanding the Role of the Nigerian Police Force Gender Unit in Addressing Violence against Women in Ekiti State, Nigeria’ (2021) 1 Nigerian Journal of Peace, Development & Humanitarian Affairs 29
Tchoukou JA, ‘Regulating Gender Violence in Postcolonial Societies: Is Legal Pluralism a Problem for Human Rights?’ (2025) 17 Journal of Human Rights Practice 22
